Follow Us

Teal Group gathers, classifies, and analyzes information from a wide range of sources. Our analysts publish News Briefs several times a year. Subscribe via email to receive each News Brief when it is published or join our mailing list to receive updates quarterly.

View All News Briefs     Subscribe Via Email     Join Mailing List

10 October 2014

NASA's Commercial Crew Vehicles: Practical But Not Sexy

Marco A. Caceres, Senior Space Analyst

NASA's Commercial Crew Vehicles: Practical But Not Sexy

The two Commercial Crew Transportation Capability (CCtCap) contracts awarded to Boeing and SpaceX by NASA on September 16 should come as no big surprise to anyone familiar with both the agency's conservative culture and its relatively small annual budget of just under $18 billion. Boeing received $4.2 billion to continue with development of its human-rated system based on the Atlas V rocket and CST-100 capsule, while SpaceX got $2.6 billion to continue work on its Falcon 9 v1.1 rocket and Dragon V2 combo. The idea is for the two systems to be ready by 2017 to begin flying American astronauts to the International Space Station (ISS) so the United States can start to wean itself from its dependency on Russia.

Boeing and SpaceX beat out a proposal by Sierra Nevada based on the Atlas V and a reusable spaceplane called Dream Chaser.

Currently, NASA is paying the Russian space agency Rosaviakosmos about $71 million (per seat) to carry its astronauts to ISS aboard Soyuz rockets and capsules. The agency has been doing this since the end of the Space Shuttle program in 2011. The cooperative arrangement has worked well. NASA gets cheap and safe rides to the station for its astronauts, while Rosaviakosmos earns some much needed hard currency. Everyone's a winner.

The problem now is that the relationship between the US and Russian governments has gone south. During the past year, due to Russia's annexation of the Crimea and interventionism in eastern Ukraine, the resultant economic sanctions against Russia by the West, and US meddling in Syria, the US-Russian relationship has grown unstable, and thus unreliable -- certainly from NASA's standpoint.

NASA can no longer take it for granted that Rosaviaskosmos will continue to sell it rides to ISS. It is entirely possible that the Russian government's Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Rogozin, who heads his country's defense and space industries, may wake up on the wrong side of the bed one day and announce Russia will no longer transport NASA astronauts to ISS. That would pose a political nightmare for the US. We'd be grounded. No way to get to our $100 billion space station.

In short, NASA has a very narrow window of opportunity to develop an American manned spaceflight capability. It has to be done in about 3-4 years in order to minimize the chance that the US will be grounded without any near-term options. That's one of the reasons NASA chose to go with the Boeing and SpaceX proposals, and not Sierra Nevada's Dream Chaser.

While Dream Chaser would have stood a much better chance of exciting the public (particularly the youth) about human spaceflight than the CST-100 and Dragon V2 capsules, going with a sleek looking reusable spaceplane may have been riskier from both a time and money standpoint -- neither of which NASA has in abundance these days. It's a shame, because Dream Chaser is a beautiful vehicle. It's essentially the upgraded version of NASA's old HL-20 test vehicle. Oh yeah, it also starred in one of my favorite sci-fi TV shows of all time, Farscape. I'm afraid capsules just don't have the same sex appeal.

About the Author

Marco A. Cáceres

Marco A. Cáceres

Marco joined Teal Group in March 1990. Previously, he was a market analyst for Jane's Information Group of the UK. As editor of both the Jane's DMS Defense & Aerospace Agencies and DMS Electronic Systems publications, Marco analyzed and wrote about the R&D and procurement activities within the defense- and aerospace-related agencies of the federal government, with a focus on the markets for major electronic warfare (EW) subsystems. Additionally, Marco edited Jane's DMS Budget Intelligence newsletter -- a weekly covering defense budget news.

Teal Group offers online access to all our products through the web. Contact our Sales Staff to obtain a user ID and password for online access. Instructions for accessing the Online Demo are found below. You will only have access to the Online Demo product. You will need Adobe Acrobat Reader to read the reports on the online access site.


  1. Log on using Demo User ID 2306 and Demo Password teal.
  2. A list of Teal Group Products will appear on the next screen.
  3. You will have access to the online demo and you will be able to see what is available in other services. Accessible reports will appear as clickable text in red under the Title of the Briefing. You will not be able to access reports in unsubscribed services. These report titles will appear as normal text in black.
  4. Click on "Online Demo". The various briefing titles will appear. Click on a section and the sample reports in that section will appear. At this point you can click on the sample report to access the file.


To inquire about online access and site licenses please contact Mr. Tim Storey.